The Messy Middle is Product Management

Scott Belsky, Author of “The Messy Middle” and Chief Product Officer at Adobe, discusses the arch of a company’s lifecycle and how leaders can successfully guide their teams through the peaks and valleys.

Scott Belsky co-founded Behance, which was acquired by Adobe in 2010 for $150 million. He then became Chief Product Officer at Adobe, where he’s focused on modernizing legacy products such as Photoshop. Scott has also been an early-stage investor and active advisor to companies including Uber, Warby Parker, Pinterest, Periscope and Sweetgreen. Through these experience, he’s gained an acute understanding of how companies evolve and how to lead teams through the inevitable ups and downs.

When people first begin a startup or a small innovation team within a big company, there’s a great deal of excitement. People often focus on the origin stories of Steve Jobs or Jeff Bezos working from their garages and celebrate the end result, but in doing so, they often gloss over the what Scott calls “messy middle,” a volatile period of ups and downs where organizations realize that they don’t know what they are doing. Strategies that used to work stop working, and dreams of becoming the next Steve Jobs start to get cloudy.

Because humans are all born with hard wired short term reward systems, Scott says that long term goals are simply not enough to keep teams engaged. Leaders have to synthetically create short term rewards to help their teams endure the valleys of the messy middle. These smaller-scale metrics create the throughline achieving a vision.

Scott stresses the importance of making the team feel like they’re making progress by sharing an example: if you’re taking a 10-day road trip with blacked-out rear windows, the people in the back will go crazy unless you narrate what milestones you are reaching along the way. At Behance, this meant working to get the Google search algorithm to stop suggesting “enhance” instead of “behance.” This wasn’t the only thing that the company needed to accomplish in order to be successful, but it was one important step along the way.

Scott argues that innovating in a big company is not all that different from building a startup. Making a change in a big company requires essentially building a new team, which will face the same doubts, resource constraints, and difficulty in keeping the team engaged.

Scott therefore stresses the importance of building the right culture. There needs to be a shared belief that the team welcomes risk taking such that team members feel psychologically safe.

Moreover, teams that value resourcefulness over resources are more likely to succeed, he says. Scott gives the analogy that resources are like carbs—you blow right through them—whereas resourcefulness is like muscle. Teams therefore ought to appreciate the times when they don’t have many resources, because that’s when they build that “muscle memory” of resourcefulness.

You’ll learn a lot in this episode about leadership, entrepreneurship, and overcoming challenges.

Here are the highlights:

Scott Belsky

Adobe’s Chief Product Officer and Author of “The Messy Middle”

Scott’s Recommended Resources on The Messy Middle

What Scott is Reading Right Now

Scott’s Favorite New Product Outside of Work


Put our guest's advice into action.

Alpha is the fastest way to learn about your future customers.

Learn More

Subscribe to receive the latest episodes and exclusive resources

Related Episodes


Growing SaaS Companies is Product Management

Kyle Poyar, Senior Director of Market Strategy at OpenView Partners, an expansion stage venture capital firm, shares the most effective SaaS pricing and packaging strategies, why product led growth is so important, and the most important SaaS metrics.

Listen to Episode

Building Freemium Products is Product Management

Michael Pici, Director of Product, Growth at Hubspot, shares how he’s launched freemium products to drive adoption of Hubspot’s premium products, and how the company’s go-to-market strategy shifted as it expanded from a single product to a platform.

Listen to Episode

Vision and Strategy is Product Management

Marty Cagan, Partner at Silicon Valley Product Group and Author of Inspired: How to Create Tech Products Customers Love, shares how to craft product vision and strategy, modern best practices for product roadmapping, and his framework for prioritizing opportunities.

Listen to Episode

Read our 2020 Product Management Insights Report

Get Report